CJP flags gaps in Maharashtra UCC consultation, submits recommendations for a gender-just civil code The 37-question survey, largely framed around yes-or-no answers, cannot adequately address complex questions on marriage, divorce, inheritance, religious freedom and equality

17, Nov 2026 | CJP Team

The proposed Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in Maharashtra is facing pointed questions from women’s rights and civil liberties groups, with organisations challenging not only the substance of the proposed framework but also the process through which the state government is seeking public opinion. In two separate submissions, Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP) and Maharashtra Stree Mukti Parishad have raised concerns over the consultation exercise, the absence of adequate representation for marginalised communities and women’s organisations, and the risk that a law presented in the language of uniformity could deepen existing inequalities rather than dismantle them.

Their submissions place a central question before the Maharashtra government: can a civil code claim to advance equality when the process of drafting it does not adequately include the people whose rights and personal lives it proposes to regulate?

CJP, in a submission dated November 6, 2026, has called for a rights-based, gender-just and genuinely inclusive civil framework. It argues that the government’s questionnaire, comprising 37 questions, 31 of which invite a simple yes-or-no response, reduces a complex constitutional and social debate to a binary exercise. The organisation maintains that citizens cannot meaningfully endorse or reject a law whose substantive provisions, legal consequences and safeguards have not been made clear.

“How can a respondent endorse a UCC without knowing what its substantive provisions will be, whose legal and cultural practices it will recognise, what discriminatory practices it intends to reform, and what safeguards will protect individual rights?” CJP asks in its submission.

The organisation argues that a questionnaire cannot substitute for meaningful public consultation, much less be treated as a mandate for legislation. The question, it says, is not merely whether Maharashtra should have a UCC, but what kind of code the government intends to introduce, whose interests it will serve and whether it will uphold constitutional guarantees of equality, dignity, liberty and freedom of religion.

Uniformity cannot become a route to majoritarianism

CJP’s central objection is that uniformity, by itself, does not guarantee gender justice. A common legal framework could still reproduce discrimination if its provisions are drawn from the practices of one dominant community and imposed on everyone else. The organisation warns that reform of personal laws must not become a selective exercise in which minority practices are scrutinised while discriminatory provisions or privileges within the majority community escape the same examination.

It argues that personal laws and customary practices must be assessed across communities against constitutional standards. The objective should be to identify and remove discriminatory provisions while retaining progressive protections that already exist in different legal traditions. A new code, CJP says, must draw upon the most egalitarian and rights-protective principles available, rather than simply replace one unequal framework with another.

The submission also challenges the assumption that religious freedom and gender equality are necessarily incompatible. Religious freedom must be protected, it argues, but cannot serve as a blanket justification for practices that violate fundamental rights. Equally, the State cannot use the language of equality to impose the customs or legal principles of one religion as the common national standard.

CJP has suggested that terms such as “Gender Just Civil Code” or “Common Civil Code” may better convey the objective of reform than “Uniform Civil Code”. Its concern is that uniformity can imply the erasure of nuance and diversity, whereas the purpose of a common civil framework should be equal rights and equal legal protection.

The organisation has also pointed to what it sees as majoritarian bias within existing secular legislation itself. It flags the continued recognition of Hindu Undivided Families under tax law as an example requiring scrutiny, arguing that a supposedly secular legal framework must also be examined for provisions that confer community-specific benefits.

It further draws attention to Section 21A of the Special Marriage Act, 1954, introduced through the Marriage Laws (Amendment) Act, 1976. The provision creates a specific exception for couples who profess Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh or Jain religions and marry under the Special Marriage Act, in relation to certain consequences otherwise provided under Sections 19 and 21. CJP argues that this differential treatment within a secular marriage law must be considered when assessing whether existing legal frameworks are genuinely neutral.

The point, the organisation maintains, is that a proposed common code cannot claim neutrality while ignoring inequalities and differential treatment embedded in laws that are already in force.

CJP flags sweeping rule-making and executive powers in the draft

Beyond the consultation process and the broader constitutional questions, CJP has raised concerns about two provisions in the circulated draft: Section 13, which concerns the government’s power to make rules, and Section 14, which concerns its power to remove difficulties.

On Section 13, CJP argues that the draft does not provide sufficient detail about the rules through which the legislation would be implemented. Leaving important aspects to be determined later, it warns, could allow substantive qualifications, conditions and consequences to be introduced through subordinate rules without adequate public scrutiny.

The organisation points to Section 4(3) of the proposed legislation, which provides for a penalty for failure to register a marriage. CJP says the draft does not adequately explain how the penalty would operate, leaving questions about its scale and application to be addressed through rules. It warns that this could create scope for arbitrary action by the State, police or other authorities, particularly where civil matters concerning marriage and divorce are increasingly subjected to criminal consequences. It has called for the proposed rules to be circulated for public commentary rather than framed after the legislation is enacted.

Section 14 has attracted a separate objection. The provision empowers the State government to issue orders to remove difficulties in giving effect to the Act. CJP describes the power as vague and disproportionate, warning that it could leave room for questionable or discriminatory measures to be introduced through executive orders. Any substantive correction to a law, it argues, should be made through the legislative amendment process, with public discussion and scrutiny in the State Assembly, rather than being left to the government bureaucracy.

These are concerns about the potential reach of the provisions, rather than claims that such powers have already been misused. CJP’s broader argument is that legislation governing intimate family relationships requires clear limits on executive discretion and safeguards against arbitrary enforcement.

Marriage, divorce, inheritance and the limits of state intervention

CJP’s submission also sets out a detailed position on the rights that a gender-just civil framework should guarantee. It calls for equal rights in marriage, divorce, maintenance, inheritance, succession, adoption and guardianship, irrespective of religion or community.

On marriage, the organisation has said that the existing minimum legal age of 18 years for women and 21 years for men should be retained. It supports accessible marriage and divorce registration, but cautions against turning registration into a mechanism of surveillance or state control over private relationships. Religious ceremonies may continue, provided they do not undermine individual rights or constitutional protections.

On divorce, CJP calls for equal grounds and procedures for spouses, safeguards against arbitrary or unilateral repudiation, and protection against coercive conditions imposed on individuals seeking to remarry. It also argues that maintenance provisions must account for economic dependence and unpaid domestic and care work, rather than treating financial contributions as the only measure of a spouse’s contribution to a marriage.

Inheritance and succession must similarly be governed by equality and non-discrimination. Women, including daughters and widows, must enjoy equal rights, and children must not lose their rights to maintenance or inheritance because their parents were not married. The submission calls for matrimonial property protections that recognise unpaid household work and caregiving, alongside financial contributions.

CJP’s approach is not to assume that every existing personal law is discriminatory or that one community’s framework should become the template for all others. It argues that the government should examine the protections available across different legal traditions and retain provisions that advance equality and protect women and children.

The organisation is particularly opposed to bringing live-in relationships within a regime of compulsory registration or state monitoring. It argues that adults must retain the freedom to choose whether to marry or live together, and that the State’s role should be to protect people from violence, abandonment and economic exploitation, not to regulate the relationship itself. Legal protection for women and children, it says, must not be made conditional on the formal registration of a private relationship.

The submission also calls for equal rights and responsibilities towards children irrespective of their parents’ marital status, and for accessible remedies for people facing domestic violence, economic abuse, coercion or abandonment. It stresses that reform must address the practical barriers people face in asserting civil rights, including high legal costs, procedural delays, complicated documentation and inadequate legal awareness.

The complete submission may be read here.

 

Maharashtra Stree Mukti Parishad questions committee composition and consultation process

The concerns raised by CJP find an important parallel in a separate statement submitted by Maharashtra Stree Mukti Parishad, a forum established through the collective efforts of feminist organisations, activists and scholars in the state. The Parishad has questioned the composition and functioning of the committee appointed by the Maharashtra government to prepare the proposed UCC. It says the committee, constituted in July 2026, was formed without taking all sections of society into confidence and that the criteria used to select its members have not been adequately explained.

According to the Parishad, the committee does not include representatives of minority communities, Adivasis, Dalits, nomadic and denotified communities, women’s organisations or the LGBTQI community. It also points to the absence of feminist activists and scholars with long-standing experience of working on family laws and gender justice. The forum argues that a committee constituted without these voices cannot adequately address the inequalities and lived realities the proposed legislation will affect.

The statement also refers to the September resignation of former judge R. C. Chavan, who had been appointed to the committee. It says Chavan cited differences over the process of seeking public feedback, the absence of substantive discussions at meetings and the presence of people who were not committee members. The Parishad argues that the concerns cited in his resignation raise questions about the committee’s functioning. It further objects to the government’s decision to appoint an official from outside Maharashtra in his place, rather than reconsider the committee’s composition and functioning. The Parishad has demanded that representatives of the excluded groups be appointed to the committee before it proceeds with its work.

Its statement also invokes the 2018 report of the 21st Law Commission of India, which examined the reform of family laws after consultations with organisations and citizens. The Commission had concluded that a Uniform Civil Code was “neither desirable nor feasible at this stage” and instead recommended the codification of personal laws to address gender inequality, the removal of discriminatory provisions in personal and secular laws, and the preservation of cultural diversity, subject to constitutional guarantees.

The Parishad has urged the Maharashtra government to consider and implement these recommendations rather than proceed with the present exercise. Its position is that gender justice requires the reform of discriminatory laws, not necessarily the creation of a single uniform framework.

Questions over live-in regulation and the exclusion of LGBTQI concerns

The Parishad has also criticised the questionnaire for what it sees as assumptions built into its questions. It points, for instance, to a question on a common system for registering marriages, divorces and live-in relationships, arguing that the question presumes that live-in relationships are to be registered even though the need for such regulation should itself be open to debate.

It raises a similar concern about the question on making financially capable adult children responsible for maintaining dependent parents. The Parishad says this framing ignores the experiences of queer and transgender people who may have faced violence or rejection within their families and may not wish to be legally compelled to care for family members who failed to care for them.

The statement argues that the questionnaire has not meaningfully addressed the rights and concerns of LGBTQI people. It refers to the Supreme Court’s October 2023 judgment on petitions seeking legal recognition of same-sex marriage, in which the Court held that changes to the legal framework for recognising same-sex marriages or civil unions were for the legislature to consider. The Parishad says the government’s consultation should not use the absence of marriage equality as a reason to overlook the rights and vulnerabilities of LGBTQI people in family and civil matters.

The forum has also drawn attention to the concerns of deserted and single women, orphaned children, persons with disabilities, elderly people without family support and LGBTQI individuals experiencing domestic violence. It says the questionnaire does not adequately seek views on how these groups can be protected.

The Parishad further questions whether the government will genuinely consider public feedback, referring to earlier consultations on the Maharashtra Special Public Security Act, 2024, and the Maharashtra Freedom of Religion Act, 2026. It says suggestions submitted during those exercises were not considered, and fears that the UCC consultation could similarly become a formality rather than an opportunity to influence legislation.

It contrasts the present process with the consultations involving women’s organisations and activists during the formulation of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, following the Justice Verma Committee’s work. The Parishad argues that the exclusion of women’s organisations from the UCC committee marks a departure from that participatory approach.

The Parishad has demanded that the exercise based on the present questionnaire be stopped, that the 2018 Law Commission recommendations be considered, and that any draft prepared by the committee be made publicly available before it is finalised. It has called for extensive consultations with diverse communities and has sought a meeting with the state government to discuss its objections.

The complete submission may be read here.

 

A common demand: consultation before legislation

Despite approaching the issue from different points, the two submissions converge on a fundamental demand: a law that claims to protect equality cannot be drafted through an opaque or exclusionary process. CJP calls for the proposed framework to be judged by the rights it guarantees and the discriminatory structures it dismantles, rather than by the promise of uniformity. Maharashtra Stree Mukti Parishad questions whether the committee and consultation process, as presently constituted, can adequately represent the people whose lives the law would regulate.

Both submissions insist that women cannot be treated as a single, homogenous category. Their experiences are shaped by caste, religion, tribe, class, sexuality, disability and economic position. A consultation that does not meaningfully include women from these communities risks reproducing the very exclusions that gender-just reform should address.

The demand is not for the protection of discriminatory practices in the name of religion or custom. It is for reform that is constitutional, inclusive and equally applicable, without turning the personal laws of minority communities into the sole focus of scrutiny or treating the practices of the majority as the default model.

Before proceeding with legislation, the Maharashtra government must disclose the proposed framework, explain the safeguards it contains, make the draft available for public scrutiny and demonstrate how submissions from affected communities have shaped its provisions. Without these steps, the consultation risks becoming a means of collecting responses to a decision that citizens have had little opportunity to influence. A common civil framework must be measured by whether it secures equal rights, dignity and autonomy for all, not by how uniformly it regulates people’s lives.

Related:

Assam NRC: Neither rejection slips for the excluded nor identity cards for those included

Census 2027: Who is the government allowing to collect your data?

SIR Must Go: Defending the right to vote

Justice for Shaheen and Nafisa Khan: CJP launches petition demanding FIR and independent probe into alleged police assault

CJP complaints document Maharashtra hate speeches targeting Muslims and promoting exclusion & inflammatory public mobilisation

 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Go to Top
Nafrat Ka Naqsha 2023