02, Aug 2018 | Zamser Ali
Members of India’s fifth President FA Ahmed have been left out of the National Register of Citizens (NRC). Now questions are being raised about the insensate practices followed by the NRC authorities during the update process that failed to consider natural calamities like floods that affect Legacy Documents of thousands. The unprofessional and tardy actions of the Election Commission of India (ECI) are also responsible for the labeling of legitimate citizens as ‘D’ Voters and ‘DF’s (Declared Foreigners) in large numbers.
Ziauddin Ali Ahmed, a simple man of about 50 years is a marginal farmer. But farming is not sufficient to run his small family of four, so, he also works as seasonal fisherman. Still, this man who lives a simple life, commands respect from the villagers of Barkukuria as ‘landlord’. Barkukuria is located in the Kamrup (Rural) District and falls under the Rangia Police Station of Assam. Other than his two sons, he has no other blood relations in the village, and yet commands this deep respect and affection.
Over 4 million people have been left out of the NRC final draft! Most of them belong to socio-economically backward communities and live in rural areas. Many of them are women and children! Now CJP, drawing from its previous experience in providing legal aid in Gujarat, will step in with a multi-faceted team of lawyers and volunteers to ensure that these people receive a fair chance while filing claims across 15 of the worst affected districts. Your contribution can help cover the costs of a legal team, travel, documentation and technological expenses. Donate Now!
Though the villagers have not paid any ‘tenancy’ to the family of landlords in the last 45 years, Ziauddin has not complained about this before any competent authority. Ziauddin is an exceptional member of an exceptional family, of none other than Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed, the fifth President of India. Ziauddin is his nephew. He is also the grandson of Lieutenant Colonel Jalnur Ali Ahmed, who is the first person to have passed the MBBS degree and qualified as a doctor in Assam.
Despite coming from such an extraordinary background, Ziauddin Ali Ahmed, remained blissfully in the dark until the release of the final draft of the NRC on July 30, 2018. Now his plight is in the limelight, with the national and international media focusing on this ‘story’… that Ziauddin Ali Ahmed, nephew of the former President of India, Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed and his family members, among 40,07,707 others have been dropped from the draft NRC. The NRC is being updated to facilitate the detention and deportation of, all foreigners from Assam.
When his case came to light, we along with young journalist Nayanjit Kalita, reached the village and hut of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed on August 1. When we reached his house, all the villagers gathered around and expressed their anguish on how a nephew of a former President of India Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed, one of the most respected person of Assam was dropped from the draft list of NRC! It appeared unbelievable that a nephew of a former first citizen of India living in such humble conditions, at a time when the son of a prominent politician of the ruling party has increased his personal wealth and property by over 5000 times within a year!
Our inquiries revealed that it was due to the absence of Legacy Data, that he couldn’t apply for NRC. We prodded further: inquired about why, other than the Legacy Data, other (alternative) documents like land holdings, School, Board and University Certificates, Birth Certificates, Passport which could have submitted as alternative documents for NRC, were not considered? The reply is shocking, and humbling. The fact that the NRC has not factored this in reveals the flaws in an exercise, expected to be both thorough and fair.
Floods Destroy Documents in Assam
According to Ziauddin, all the documents they had, have been washed away in the devastating floods of 1984. For getting the Legacy Data and some other documents the poor man, along with his son went from pillar to post, across the state. They even searched Delhi and some other places where ever Lieutenant Colonnel Jalnur Ali Ahmed, Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed lived. But they could not find anything about his father!
Since the villagers of Barkukuria in Kamrup district had consistent claims of tenancy from the lands of Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed and his family members, we then inquired further, about the land documents of that village. There had been some doubts expressed about the relationship between Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed and the father of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed, Ahtramuddin Ali Ahmed. However, this ‘myth’ was busted when the villagers submitted some receipts of land taxes. Some of these receipts were signed by Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed (himself), and others were signed by Ahtramuddin Ali Ahmed. The mis-spelling of the name of the father of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed in the ‘mainstream’ media who called him Akramuddin Ali Ahmed had caused this particular bit of confusion. The elderly villagers said that Ahtramuddin Ali Ahmed and Akramuddin Ali Ahmed are one and the same person. Ahtramuddin Ali Ahmed @ Akramuddin Ali Ahmed was an engineer, who was never serious about the family and property. He led a simple, even mysterious life. So, he came to be known as Pagla Baba (Mad Baba).
Meanwhile, we investigated the Cadestral (Land) report of Barkukuria and nearby villages. Here all confusion ends. There is a distinct noting that the entire land is under the joint ownership of ten Persons. They are Fakharuddin Ali Ahmed, Jalaluddin Ali Ahmed, Ahtramuddin Ali Ahmed, two other male and five other female members who are all sons and daughters of Lieutenant Colonel Jalnur Ali Ahmed. This is a big relief for Jalaluddin Ali Ahmed and his family! This is in all likelihood a valid document for Jalaluddin Ali Ahmed for the inclusion of his name in the final NRC.
Absence from Electoral Rolls
But the worries do not end here for Jalaluddin Ali Ahmed. Jalaluddin Ali Ahmed still has no valid document for establishing his Linkage with his father! The only available document that would have been an acceptable is the Voter Identity Card which he has, but over that he faces another problem. Though the land documents show that father of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed is recorded as Ahtramuddin Ali Ahmed, in the Voters identity Card and in Voters List son of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed is recorded as Akram Ali.
Under these circumstances, only if the Election Commission of India allows ‘special permission’ (sic) for the correction of the Voters List and issues directions with this special permission for the correction of the Voters Identity Card of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed, only then he will able to submit special application for inclusion of their names in NRC!
Have they undertaken this procedure? Sajid Ali Ahmed, who is son of Ziauddin Ali Ahmed says, “I have applied for correction of my Father’s Name including the name recorded in the Voters list as my Grandfather two years ago. But the Election Commission has never paid any attention to my application. If we are kept out of the NRC because of this complacency, who will be responsible?”
It is not only the pain of Sajid Ali Ahmed, but hundreds of thousands of people of Assam. For the irresponsible and tardy behaviour of the Election Commission of India (ECI), lakhs of people have been unlawfully designated D Voter and Declared Foreigners!